The best hockey evaluation software, compared honestly.
Four real tools, compared on whether they're built for hockey specifically, whether they cover a full season or just the tryout, and who they're actually best for. We make one of these tools, Hockey Coach Hub, and we say so plainly below rather than pretending this is a neutral outside review.
Last updated September 5, 2026
What we're judging on
Hockey-specific vs multi-sport
Skater and goalie criteria built in, or a generic template you adapt yourself.
Tryout tool vs season-long tool
Does it end when tryouts do, or does it carry into evaluations, development, and feedback all year.
Multi-evaluator averaging
Can your full coaching staff score independently, with results blended automatically.
Pricing model
Flat per-team pricing vs per-player pricing, since per-player costs scale differently as your roster grows.
Four options, and who each is actually for
Hockey Coach Hub
That's usBest for: Hockey-only programs that want the season, not just the tryout
Covers the full season around the evaluation: player goals, multi-coach evaluations with hockey-specific skater and goalie criteria, check-ins, off-ice challenges, and personalized development feedback drafted from all of it. Includes Tryout Mode for live bench-side grading.
Pricing: Free for 2 months (1 team, up to 20 players), then $9/month for up to 25 players
See how it compares to TeamGenius →TeamGenius
Best for: Clubs running tryouts across more than one sport
Multi-sport evaluation and tryout software with sport-specific templates, in-app video capture during evaluations, and a report card feature for end-of-season feedback filled in manually by the coach. Integrates with SportsEngine, TeamSnap, and LeagueApps for roster sync.
Pricing: 14-day free trial (up to 20 players), tiered Starter/Pro/Elite plans
Full comparison →SkillShark
Best for: Hockey-only programs that want live video scoring during tryouts
A hockey-specific evaluation app: custom evaluation forms, live video and voice-to-text scoring on any device, and auto-generated report cards with rankings and benchmarks sent minutes after an evaluation. Built around tryouts and evaluation events rather than a full season workflow of goals, check-ins, and challenges.
Pricing: Free for your first 25 players, then $5 to $15 per player depending on tier
Rank One Sport
Best for: Large, multi-team organizations standardizing rubrics across many evaluators
Evaluation software aimed at bigger, standardized programs, athletic departments and associations running tryouts across many teams with a consistent rubric and a large evaluator pool. Multi-sport, not hockey-specific.
Pricing: Contact for pricing
Side by side
| Hockey Coach Hub | TeamGenius | SkillShark | Rank One Sport | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hockey-specific | Yes | Multi-sport | Yes | Multi-sport |
| Beyond tryouts: goals, check-ins, challenges | Yes | No | No | No |
| Multi-coach averaging | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| End-of-season feedback | AI-drafted, automatic | Manual report card | Manual report card | Not documented |
| Pricing model | Flat, per team | Flat, per team | Per player | Contact for pricing |
Also worth knowing about
TryoutHQ
A purpose-built app for scoring a single tryout event quickly. Works well for the day itself, but doesn't carry a roster into season-long evaluations, goals, or feedback, you'd rebuild that elsewhere.
Crossbar (PlayMetrics)
Primarily a registration, scheduling, and payments platform rather than an evaluation tool. Hockey Coach Hub can import a roster directly from a Crossbar URL if your club already uses it for registration.
Common questions
What is the best hockey evaluation software?
It depends what you need. For hockey-only programs that want season-long development, not just a tryout score, Hockey Coach Hub covers goals, evaluations, check-ins, challenges, and feedback in one tool. For a club running tryouts across multiple sports, TeamGenius is a strong fit. For hockey-only live video scoring during tryouts specifically, SkillShark is built for that. For large, standardized multi-team programs, Rank One Sport focuses on rubric consistency across many evaluators.
Is there hockey-specific evaluation software, or only multi-sport tools?
Both exist. Hockey Coach Hub and SkillShark are built specifically for hockey. TeamGenius and Rank One Sport are multi-sport platforms that include hockey templates.
What's the difference between tryout software and season-long evaluation software?
Tryout software, like TryoutHQ or SkillShark's core use case, is built to score one event quickly and produce rankings. Season-long software carries that same roster into ongoing evaluations, player goals, check-ins, and end-of-season feedback, so the tryout isn't a separate step you have to reconnect to the rest of the season.
Does hockey evaluation software support multiple coaches scoring independently?
Hockey Coach Hub, TeamGenius, SkillShark, and Rank One Sport all support multiple evaluators. Hockey Coach Hub and TeamGenius average scores from your full coaching staff automatically into one blended view.
How is this list put together?
We built this to be genuinely useful for choosing evaluation software, not just to promote Hockey Coach Hub. We're included because we think a hockey-only, season-long approach is the right one for hockey programs specifically, but the other tools here are real, verified options and each is a better fit for some programs than we are.
Try the season-long option free.
2 months free, one team, up to 20 players, no credit card required.
Start free →